On November 15, West Bengal saw its fifth police ‘encounter’ since Suvendu Adhikari took over as chief minister of the state’s first BJP government in May. The deceased, Ratan Sheikh, 31, was wanted in 36 cases, and had allegedly fired at and injured a cop in Santiniketan two days before. Sheikh was shot dead in retaliatory fire after he is said to have pulled out a concealed weapon while in custody. The incident, per se, would not have made the front pages but for the CM’s standard response on the possible extra-judicial action. “If someone tries to kill the police, will they throw flowers back?” he asked reporters. A week before, after the fourth ‘encounter’, the analogy had been about roshogullas instead of flowers.

