France’s interior minister appears to have quietly made it easier for foreign retirees to become French citizens, even though important questions remain. The Local’s Emma Pearson asks why the minister isn’t telling everyone about the move.
Changes that will make life harder for foreigners in France are more often than not announced with drumrolls, fanfare, press conferences and plenty of headlines.
Changes that will make life easier for foreigners in France, by contrast, seem to slip out unnoticed.
Just such a change has now been made, when Interior Minister Laurent Nunez announced that tough new rules on French citizenship have been “adapted”, so that foreign retirees are no longer barred from becoming French on the grounds that their income is comprised of a foreign pension.
In a letter, he writes: “les modalités d’examen des demandes de naturalisation des personnes retraitées ont été adaptées, afin de mieux tenir compte de la spécificité et de la diversité de leurs situations.” (The procedures for assessing applications for naturalisation from retired people have been adapted to take better account of the specific nature and diversity of their circumstances.)
This might sound dull and technical, but for thousands of retirees in France that slight change of wording is the difference between being accepted or rejected for French citizenship.
Or to put it another way, the difference between the stress of having to regularly renew a residency permit and the right to remain in France for the rest of their lives as a French citizen.
In short – for those affected, it’s huge.
The adaptation by Nunez essentially corrects a botched ministerial memo issued by his predecessor Bruno Retailleau.
Back in May 2025, when he issued his circulaire that toughened up the rules, Retailleau called a press conference, made a long speech in praise of himself and his own toughness on immigration, and secured headlines in most of the French papers.
The adaptation by Nunez has, apparently, already gone into effect – but seems to have had no major announcement.
If it hadn’t been for Senator Nicole Bonnefoy, who had written to him asking for an update, and then posted his reply on Facebook, we might never have known.
Now that we do know, we are of course shouting it from the rooftops – because there’s no point making a change if no one knows about it. Many foreign pensioners in France still believe that there is no point in even applying for citizenship, because of the tough income rules.
There remain, however, some important questions about his announcement, which we are endeavouring to get answers to from the Interior Ministry.
Has the change already been communicated to the préfectures?
Should eligible foreigners apply now or wait for a formal decree?
What about those who had already been rejected under the tougher income requirements – do they have the right to appeal or must they start the whole process again?
It’s unclear at this stage, and we are pressing for answers to these very reasonable questions.
But what explains the disparities in these two announcements?
Partly, I believe, it is the personalities and political ambitions of the ministers involved.
Retailleau, like his predecessor at the Interior Ministry, Gérald Darmanin, is an ambitious politician determined to build his political brand. Retailleau is now the leader of the Les Républicians party and is standing for president in 2027 – a large part of his programme is about getting tough on immigration.
Nunez, by contrast, was a technocrat appointment to the Interior Ministry, drafted in by prime minister Sébastien Lecornu as he was desperately trying to build a government that would last more than five minutes.
He is a civil servant, building his career through high-level positions within préfectures and local authorities, before rising to become the Paris police chief (which is a fonctionnaire appointment, rather than a serving officer promoted from within the ranks).
Since taking up his post in October 2025, Nunez has – on immigration matters at least – marked himself out as a pragmatist, prioritising smoothly functioning préfectures over spiteful persecution of immigrants.
Among the changes he has enacted are recruiting new préfecture staff and setting targets on carte de séjour processing times to try and lessen the long waits to renew residency permits.
He has also issued guidance to préfectures to allow them to treat applications with the minimum supporting documents, and also to give long-term residency permits where possible, rather than requiring people to renew yearly.
Exactly how much impact this will have on the spiralling waiting times at préfectures remains to be seen, but the accent is clearly on streamlining and efficiency.
READ ALSO: LATEST: What French Interior Minister’s plan means for your carte de séjour application
The citizenship change is, in effect, more of the same – it gives back discretion to local préfectures and allows them to make a decision based on the whole application, rather than being prescriptive about income sources.
Again, these might sound like tedious administrative changes – but for foreigners caught up in the stress-filled nightmare of their residency permit running out or being denied over a technicality, they are a godsend.
For foreign pensioners who might, after all, be able to become French, they are nothing short of life-changing.
They’re also very rare – in the seven years that I have been reporting on immigration related matters for The Local, the direction of travel has all been the other way; every speech, every new law, every ministerial memo is about making things more difficult for immigrants.
It’s got to the point where I’m ready to form a vocal-harmony choir to sing songs in praise of Nunez simply for his clarification of the dossier requirements for a carte de séjour renewal application.
And that, I suspect, is the second reason why this change was slipped out so quietly – this government does not want to be seen as being in any way friendly or helpful towards immigrants.
With an election looming and Marine Le Pen boasting a commanding lead in the polls, the centrists still believe that they can take her on by aping her ‘tough on immigration’ stance. A quick glance at the manifestos of the 2027 candidates reveals immigration policies from the supposed centrists that just a few years ago would have been the preserve of the right-wing, or even far-right, politicians.
READ ALSO: Compared: The French presidential candidates’ policies for foreigners in France
So it seems that, for the foreseeable future, quietly-slipped-out changes simplifying and streamlining immigration processes are the best we can hope for.
Unless, that is, the Trotskyist candidate Nathalie Arthaud wins the 2027 election – as a long-time advocate of completely open borders, President Arthaud’s regime would look very different indeed.
She’s currently polling 0.5 percent, but you never know . . .

